Tiny Tim Must Die


People with mental, physical and developmental disabilities make up 18% of the American population. That is a larger group than many ethnic, religious and sexual minorities with far more influence and advocacy than the disabled have. Perhaps far worse than a lack of advocacy is the fact that only 16% of people with disabilities graduate from college in this country, and only 30% have jobs. The government spends millions and millions of dollars supporting people with disabilities, meaning that Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid are taxed to their limits. Why aren’t Americans with disabilities expected to get off of their couches and be productive members of society like the rest of the American populace? If any other group received so many benefits while doing so little, there would be an uproar. Instead, people are too afraid to realistically look at why so much money is wasted. As an American taxpayer who has worked a paying job and who has spent money paying for services for people with disabilities, and who feels that every person receiving society’s support ought to be contributing to it as much as they can, I am outraged.

At this point, you may think that I’m almost a fascist, attacking policies that help people with disabilities. It may interest you to learn that I have never stood up or walked a single step in my life. My wheelchair means that I have received (truly needed) money from the government so that I can do such basic things as live in a home, go to school, have a motor vehicle and hold a job.

What angers me is not that the government pays for necessary services for people with disabilities, or even that some people with disabilities can’t work. I know that.

I spent last week at the National Council on Disability’s State of Disability event, listening to speakers from the Department of Education, the Department of Labor, the Department of Health and Human Services, the Social Security Administration and other federal agencies discuss ways to fix the government’s disability support services. What did we decide?

Tiny Tim must die.

The attitude that people with disabilities are unfortunate, marginalized people who need to be propped up by society is killing us. We are second-class citizens. Just as Tiny Tim went to church Christmas Eve to make people feel “grateful” for not having a disability, Americans with disabilities now get to go to work (rarely) to make companies feel good about “employing” those with impairments. As one of our speakers (most of whom have disabilities) bluntly put it, employment needs to be an expectation, not a nice idea. Also, there needs to be opportunity to work somewhere other than McDonald’s for the next twenty years.

Amazingly, the government is fostering institutions that are barriers to people with disabilities working. If you become employed and you have a disability, you have a good chance of losing medical and Social Security benefits. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think that a millionaire should receive government funding for a wooden ramp, but it is entirely ridiculous that an office manager at Staples can’t get government money to buy a $28,000 (not exaggerated, by the way) wheelchair. It is even worse that someone who could be working, but chooses not to, can receive the money instead. Shouldn’t the government be working to make people employees and taxpayers, rather than wards of the state and non-workers?

We need a system that rewards work, and helps those who truly cannot work. Yes, there are people who genuinely cannot be employed in any circumstance due to the level of their disabilities, and when you show me someone who cannot even serve as a greeter or teleworker, then I will show you someone who deserves full government benefits. They are in a slim minority, though. Otherwise, let’s fix the system. Let’s put up money that helps people with disabilities to work, not hinders them from doing so. Let’s put up money so that no American is expected to live on the couch. Let’s make dignity a federal program.

Let us live in the communities. Let us work paying jobs that we choose. Give us a role in supporting society, just as society aids us when we need it. Stop government handouts that erode a sense of personal responsibility, prevent employment and hinder the chance to live comfortably. Support programs that help workers, including those with disabilities. We need to know that, if we do manage to become employed and start paying higher income taxes, we won’t be penalized.

Give us our chance at the American dream. We’ve had enough of sitting around and letting Scrooge pay for us to do nothing.

Advertisements

6 Responses to Tiny Tim Must Die

  1. Jay says:

    Matt, great post!!!! People with disabilities have the same duty and the same call to contribute to society just as much as anyone else. The concept that they cannot work is absolutely shameful. Disabled people can support themselves and the U.S. government SHOULD support and reward those that do. Disabled people can work and should work. Many disabled people get the impression that they are “victims” and simply can’t work. This is wrong. The disabled can earn their own keep, they can contribute to society, and they certainly are cheating themselves if they think that they are limited to welfare as their primary source of income for the rest of their lives. Great post! The government should support those that work and work hard over those that can work but choose not to.

  2. Matt says:

    It’s time for the death of the attitude that disability is a shameful thing. I’m perfectly comfortable with my disability. I believe that I have as much of a right and a duty to become educated and work for the benefit of society as any other American.

    People with disabilities are a great potential asset to society. Let us be what we can be, and we’ll do our part!

  3. Rachel says:

    Superagreement w/both of you….

    Except Tiny Tim is my idol. Sorry to say.

  4. Matt says:

    Tiny Tim is a sort of Jim Crow character for people with disabilities. Pathetic, useless and a poster boy of condescension, he must die. Or, at the very least, become a productive member of society.

  5. Ian Engdahl says:

    I’m intrueged by the statistics you cited. Does the term ‘mental disabilty’ include such things as ADHD or depression?

  6. Matt says:

    Mental disability can be a pretty loose term, but I would use “mental” or “emotional” disability to describe ADHD and depression. The federal government does recognize them as disabilities, and they are protected under federal legislation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: